“The way you get to know yourself is just by making choices every day. The small choices.”
Today on Messy Middlescence, our guest Shay McKenna shares her remarkable journey into motherhood. Her story reveals the many facets and complexities that transformation can entail. It's a story of courage, determination, heartbreak, trust, and what we might even call a few miracles along the way.
Shay always knew she wanted to be a mother, but the path to making that dream a reality was a winding and difficult one. At times, it seemed almost impossible. Yet through a series of unexpected encounters, difficult decisions, and moments of clarity, a path began to emerge.
What struck us about Shay's story was the balance between taking action and letting go of control. Shay talks about getting and staying on the "trust bus," listening to herself, and focusing on the next step rather than trying to figure out the entire journey. Along the way, people and possibilities appeared that she could never have anticipated. Some might call it fate, luck, or coincidence. To us, there was something almost miraculous about how it all unfolded.
Shay's story also offers an interesting perspective on transformation. What if transformation isn't about becoming someone different, but about becoming more fully who we have always been? For Shay, following that quiet but persistent desire to become a mother ultimately helped her discover and embrace her true self.
Some of the ideas discussed in this episode include:
The power of a book (or books) to change your life;
Getting and staying on the "trust bus";
The importance of the small choices we make every day;
The idea that transformation can bring us closer to our true selves and set us free;
The need to take one step at a time when obstacles feel overwhelming;
How challenging it can be to hear your inner voice and follow your heart;
Finding the balance between taking action and letting go of control;
How an unexpected encounter can change the course of our lives.
What we loved most about Shay's story was not just her courage and tenacity, but her willingness to trust and remain open to possibilities she couldn't have imagined. Her story reminds us that we may be capable of more than we realize, that it's important to listen to our hearts, and that despite our best efforts and plans, so much of life lies beyond our control.
We don't have to know exactly where we're going. Sometimes we just need to take the next step and remain open to what life might bring. Our stories are still unfolding, and who knows what miracles might be waiting for us?
-
Tara Bansal: Welcome.
Tara: Hello. Hello. This is Tara Conti Bansal
and we are here for another episode of Messy Middlescence. I'm here with my sister, Christina Conti Donovan,
and I'm so excited and thrilled to have my good friend Shay here with us today.
I got to know Shay through Martha Beck's Wayfinder Life coach training.
And that is.
I think it's a year,
right, Shay, how long was it? I don't know. It felt like more than a year.
Yeah, nine months.
But it's pretty intense in just, like,
what you share and being vulnerable and becoming a coach and so getting to do that journey with Shay, I feel like I do know her better than just anyone, you know, off of the street.
And I think the world of her, she's just like a ray of sunshine hue.
I don't know, has this positive energy that I feel like attracts people to her.
So.
And Shay has gone through quite a few. I mean, like, all of us has many life changes she's been through,
but just in the past year,
two years, she's had some really big ones. And so I thought of her on our topic for the theme of this season around transformation, and she was gracious enough to say she would come and join us.
So welcome, Shay.
Shay: I'm so happy to be here. And just got a little.
Thank you, Tina.
I just got a little emotional even just listening to that, because it. That is a very nice compliment.
And.
And, yes, of course, I feel that we got to know each other in a really special way, and I'm just really excited to be here. And, yeah, my most recent transformation are just really very.
They're my favorite one in my. In my life.
Do
Tara: you want to jump to that or do you want to tell us more about, like, growing up and where you came from? It's up to you.
Shay: Okay, I'll just. I'll not leave anyone in suspense.
I'll just say that I became a mom. It's not like the. You know, it's a really, really common transformation, but no less
Tara: miraculous or changing.
Shay: Exactly. Exactly. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
And sure, I'll let in. My background is I've never done this before, so I'm just gonna give it a shot, you know? Like what?
I'm a.
A white Midwestern girl.
I was born in Iowa.
I kind of grew up half in Iowa and then moved to Wisconsin when I was nine.
That felt like a big deal when I was a kid. And now I realize that they're all very similar. That whole part of the world is really similar in Values and culture, culturally.
So I am from the Midwest.
I. I left as soon as I possibly could,
which makes it seem like maybe I.
I just had a rough time in high school,
you know, small, small town.
And.
Yeah, I left four days after I graduated from high school and I moved. I packed my car up and I drove to California and I went to college in California.
I went to photography school,
which was a magical experience.
Felt kind of like going to Hogwarts or something, honestly.
But I don't know that if I had to do it over again, if I would do something so specialized when I was so young.
I was 18 and I knew so much, you guys.
I felt like I did and of course realized I knew nothing. Anyway, I went to a really specialized school and.
And then I was doing photography,
commercial photography,
ever since then.
And I lived in California for a long time, almost a. Almost a decade. And then I moved across the country to New York.
Then I. So I've kind of lived a third of my life in the Midwest and then in California and now in New York.
I. I realize now I'm kind of stuck. That. That sounds very simple. And I'm kind of experiencing two big transformations at once. One is to become.
One is becoming a mother, and the other is changing my career from doing commercial photography into something else, which we can talk about if you want to talk about that.
But the.
I'm gonna stop there and let you ask another question. I hope that wasn't too rambling.
Tara: No, do you. Wow. This is me just. We're in Wisconsin.
Shay: Oh, a little tiny town outside of Madison, Wisconsin. It was like southwest, I think, of Madison, Wisconsin. It was called Mount Horeb. Very strange name. Biblical. Yeah.
Tara: Because we have a brother who lives in Madison and so we enjoy going there. Isn't
Shay: Madison such a magical little city?
Tara: It is. I
Shay: love Madison. It's
Tina: really nice.
Tara: Yeah, we love it. But it is cold in the winter. So
Shay: very cold in the winter.
Tara: Yeah. And then we're in.
Tina: What? Oh,
Tara: go ahead,
Tina: go ahead.
I was going to say, what drew you to New York? I mean, we know why you went to la.
Or I mean, to California. I don't know why I assumed it was la, maybe,
but
Shay: it's a totally normal assumption. But actually wasn't la. It was Santa Barbara is where the school was. And then after school, like many, many of my classmates, you either went to New York or San Francisco or la.
And I ended up going to San Francisco. So I was in the Bay Area, Northern California for six or seven years. And then the reason I moved to New York was just.
I felt like I was just fighting constantly to find jobs as a.
I was a photographer's assistant at the time in San Francisco,
and it just felt like a slog. And I. I thought New York might afford more opportunities.
And if I'm being really truthful, I had a tough relationship through my, like, my 20s and needed a fresh start,
needed to get out of there and start and start over. And so I moved to New York at an uncommon time. I think I was 29 when I moved to New York.
I feel like people usually move a lot earlier,
but I came for work and a fresh start.
Tara: And were you in New York City or. I know you're not in New York City now, but
Shay: I'm not. I was in Brooklyn.
Tara: Okay.
Shay: Yeah. For 12 years.
Tara: Okay.
Shay: Something like 12 years. And then again, like a lot of people,
I moved upstate New York, which is where I live now. I live in Kingston, N.Y. and I moved up here in the very beginning of the pandemic,
when New York City was a rough place to be at that time.
And I was already getting tired of the pace,
I feel like, of New York. And so I was really.
I was.
I was honestly really excited about moving up state,
moving out of a big city, because I had lived in one since I.
I mean, for past two decades, and I was ready to have some more sky and more space.
Tara: And what brought you to Kingston?
Shay: Oh, I. We had. I,
at the time, I was with a partner and we cast a super wide net. We did not have a lot of money to spend. We were. We bought a little house and we didn't have a lot of money to spend, so we were looking all over,
I mean, within three hours of New York City, three and a half even.
Didn't think it was possible, but things just kind of aligned and we ended up buying a little house that was halfway between Kingston and Woodstock.
Tara: Okay.
Shay: And I was surprised by that.
I didn't feel like we would find something that close to Kingston or Woodstock, which were very much a kind of a hub, like that's where a lot of people from the city were going.
A very popular place to land, Hudson, Kingston.
I was surprised that we landed there because it,
I guess in 2024,
which is four years post pandemic, but in 2024, Kingston, New York was the fastest growing city in the United States.
Tina: Wow, that's crazy.
Shay: Yeah.
Tara: Yeah. So you move out of New York City
Shay: at the
Tara: beginning of the pandemic, and then what happened?
Shay: Let's see. If I can say this really quickly,
the relationship that I was in was troubled. We were, we were struggling quite a bit.
And I naively kept thinking that.
I was thinking that the problems were I. My last one, the, the last hold up was thinking that we didn't have enough space. We lived in a really tiny apartment in Sunset Park, Brooklyn.
And I was thinking, hoping that moving upstate and buying a house would magically solve a lot of problems. I thought that it was the lack of space and the city and so on that was.
I'm going to say this really plainly. I really, really wanted to have a baby.
Being a mom felt like a non negotiable.
Absolutely.
I felt called to do that.
And I think in the end he really didn't want to be a parent.
And I think a lot of couples go through this actually.
I think when they're, when some, when. When it's a non negotiable for one partner or one person in the relationship, then the other partner person probably feels that they have to say yes to that or go along with that idea even if it's not what they truly desire because otherwise they would lose the relationship.
It's a tough, It's a tough situation. And I get. I don't think I'm alone, you know, I think that there are plenty of other people that go through this.
I was thinking that the space would allow our relationship to transform. And of course, you know, again, I thought like, oh, this will work anyway.
Really didn't. So I,
I think it was about a year and a half into owning a house and living upstate and there was another kind of sad thing that was happening which was that I was having like the source was unknown, but I was having.
There was reason to believe that my fertility was compromised.
But the pandemic and buying a house and the. And like trying to get the relationship back on track. There was a lot of other things going on during the same time that I was trying to.
Or that my fertility was doing weird stuff.
We were trying to get the. To the bottom of what was going on with my fertility.
And was
Tara: that a lot of doctor visits and investigation or.
Shay: Yeah, I,
I don't know if this is like to me that it always sticks out in my mind that, that I went to,
I went to see a.
Sorry, an acupuncturist that was specifically for fertility because.
And I started there instead of like just going to the. A doctor.
Yeah, like my regular doctor, a gynecologist, whatever. I, I went to an acupuncturist and was like, you know, I'm. I'm concerned about my fertility. My cycle was.
Had been irregular for a couple of years,
and I was worried about that.
And I went to see her and it. And it was a lovely visit.
And she said, you should definitely get some blood work done so we can see what's going on.
And that was on March 11th of 2020.
And on March 13th.
Yeah,
Tara: yeah,
Shay: March. The
Tina: pandemic happened
Shay: was the day world shut down. Went home from work, and we thought we'd be back in a few days, and then we thought we'd be back in a couple of weeks.
And as you both know, I think it was.
It makes me emotional thinking about was it wasn't. I think it was 18 months until I could get that blood test.
Tina: Wow.
Shay: A lot. A lot happened. You know, a lot happened.
We were all scared for our lives. For many, many months. We were.
I was washing my groceries in the sink with soap. Like, it was a really crazy time for the whole world. And so I completely.
We were just worried about survival. I was no longer thinking about my fertility. That completely went onto the back burn.
Yeah. It wasn't for a really long time until I finally got in to have just a regular old blood test.
And the results of that blood test showed that I.
I got. They were like, you're somewhere in the.
In the process of what they called premature ovarian failure.
Tina: Oh, wow. I've never heard that term.
Shay: Or they're calling it something else now. They don't want to call it just failure, I guess. But in any case,
yeah, I think the term that they used to me out loud was early menopause.
I was 39. 38 or 39,
I think, at this point.
And I felt like the Hulk.
There's any Marvel fans out there. But I wanted to pick the exam table up and throw it out the window. That's how it made me feel on the inside.
What I did was cry with tears shooting out my. Like,
they weren't even going down. They were going out.
And I think I shocked the nurse practitioner who had just given me that news. And let's see, when I was given that information,
I did not want to accept that. I think it took. I think I took at least eight or nine months of going to acupuncture weekly.
I was scrambling. I was like, really, like,
whoa.
Tara: Trying. Yeah.
Shay: Yes. I was really trying to take care of my health.
What I wasn't really doing in reality in, like,
in real life, was actually trying with my partner at the time.
I Think there was probably some subconscious knowing on my part that you should not be trying to have a baby with somebody where things are not going great for me especially.
And I'll just say that what I didn't say about my upbringing was that my parents divorced when I was 4 and my brother was 2.
And they were really young and they were doing the best they can, but that divorce was difficult.
Really difficult. It made things really, really hard and sad for a lot of reasons,
for all four of us for 30 years.
I mean, a long time.
And so as much as I wanted to be a mom,
I knew that the one thing I wasn't going to do was have,
like,
have a baby with somebody who I wasn't totally sure that it was gonna work out with.
I'm sure people will be like, well, then why were you with this person?
And it was such a struggle.
There were.
I guess that's why I was trying to explain about the pandemic and a lot. There was just a lot of other things going on,
and I was. Made it
Tara: harder and complicated
Shay: it. I was trying, you know. You know, I. There were, like, a lot of moving parts.
When I was told that my.
That my blood test numbers were showing this, like,
premature ovarian failure or early menopause or whatever you want to call it,
I went into, like, a tunnel vision of, like, just trying to get my health on track.
Yeah. Anyway, I. I think I gave myself like eight or nine months.
It was right around my 40th birthday that I finally acquiesced and gave a call to a reproductive endocrinologist because.
Tara: And were you still in that relationship?
Shay: I was still in. In the relationship.
And it was.
It was still not improving. It was continuing down.
And then I.
There. I didn't even go into her office, into the reproductive endocrinologist office. She called me on the phone after she got the results of a blood test.
She just called in a blood test. I went to, like, a quest diagnosis or whatever.
She got the results and just called me on the phone and said,
you,
like,
this is.
Your fertility is like,
that's very compromised at this point. Actually, I'm very concerned about your health because you have.
Your levels of estrogen and whatnot are very, very low. You must feel terrible.
And that is true. I did feel absolutely awful in any way. So.
That call for me was really kind of a rock bottom. It felt like the plane crashed into the mountain.
And I.
I knew what it did was wake it. I woke me up, I think,
where I was like, okay,
it is now confirmed that in order for me to have a baby,
I am going to have to be intentional in a different way.
It was what made me really understand that this person that I was with,
like was not nearly as on bored with this as I was going to need them to be. It was like I was going to have to pull myself through this situation and having help would have been great, but I was going to have to pull him as well as myself.
And I was like, I think that's. I was like that I cannot do.
And sorry, I'll just really. Super quick nod.
This was in the winter time and I spent three or four days a week hiking through the frozen woods, hiking through snow outside listening to the Way of Integrity by Martha back.
Tina: Uh huh.
Shay: Um. It's only in hindsight do I realize like just how badly I did not want to be sharing a space with a person that because I was outside hiking in the freezing cold woods every day, I was like, wow, you really don't want to be in there.
And I. How did
Tina: you find the Way to Integrity by Martha Beck? Was that something that.
Shay: You know what, it's funny. My therapist, I have a therapist,
very beloved to me. Such a spectacular person.
She recommended me.
She said, I think you should read this book by Martha Bett.
Actually it was the Rock. It was the wrong book. It wasn't the one that she recommended, but she didn't even know it was new at the time, so she just didn't know about it.
And I accidentally downloaded and read the wrong book, which ended up being
Tara: the Way of Integrity.
Shay: The Way of Integrity and the right book.
Tina: Yeah. That's so
Shay: funny. It was, it really,
it really.
I really credit that book with being one of the major reasons that I was able to see my situation more clearly and see that situation more clearly.
And so yeah, I was listening to that book.
I.
I had gotten this devastating news. I mean it was devastating for me. It felt. It was the most painful,
probably the most painful moment of my life really.
And so the one thing about,
about being,
I don't know, I guess I was gonna say is like having no choice is sort of like you're the most free that you can be.
And so I was like,
I'm gonna make some really huge changes.
Like I had not believed that I could leave that relationship. I mean there were. I just really felt like I really want to have a family. This is the only way that I can have a family is by being in a relationship,
in a romantic relationship with a person.
To have A family.
It's a pretty deeply held belief in our culture that that's what you need in order to, you know, if you are,
that you need to have a long term romantic partner to have, to have a family.
Yeah. When the plane crashed into the mountain and I was told that my fertility was like, truly very conflict compromised,
I felt like, okay, this is gonna, this is changing the,
the thing about becoming a mother. And so I just,
I,
I cut loose. Like, I don't know, it's like, you know, I just, I like, cut all the ties. Like, everything that I had going in my life, I really, like, cut it.
And I,
I mean, it took me several months, many months to do this. It wasn't until the springtime, actually, that I officially left the relationship that I was in. That was very sad.
It was difficult for, for both of us.
I know.
And,
and so,
yeah, I, I,
I was single then for like the first time really in my adult life. I mean, I hadn't been with that same person for all the time that I had been in a long term relationship pretty much since I was 14 until this point.
I was 40 years old.
And all I knew is that I wanted to be a mom.
It felt like all of that,
like that that option had been just taken away from me in every way that it could be taken away.
And I felt very raw. I was really, really in square one. I was like starting very new
Tara: and. Is that when you signed up for Martha Beck's life coach?
Shay: It was.
No, it was a couple of years into that. I did, I took like a good, I think it was like a good year and a half of being a single person for the first time in my life.
And I'm gonna tell you, there were some sad, there was definitely some sadness.
I went through a lot of grieving,
like laying on the floor kind of grieving that old life and what I thought and like,
didn't know how parenthood was gonna look. And in all honesty, I was like, oh, maybe I'll meet Charming tomorrow, Mr. Right tomorrow.
I was like, you, you did the hard thing and you ended the relationship. And like, maybe you're gonna be rewarded by like, meeting the right guy. But the truth was, I loved being single.
Tina: I
Shay: was like, this is so fun and so cool. And again, I think it was just like for the first time in my life,
I was getting to know myself. I mean, just through like, the smallest,
smallest ways. My therapist is such a spectacular person. I love her so much. And she was just like, yeah, you're just,
it You. The way you get to know yourself is just by making choices every day.
The. The small choices.
And I,
on a whim, I like, had a break from work that was unexpected.
And I drove my car to Acadia national park and went hiking.
I think I was maybe in.
I think I was in the coach training at this point. Like, I just was doing stuff that I was like,
Tina: why not try
Shay: it? Why not? Why not? Like, let's just see how it go. Like, how it goes. Like, I don't know, can I do this? Can I drive for eight hours by myself in the car?
Like, am I going to go crazy? Or like hate every second of this?
Turns out I didn't. I actually really loved it. And then I spent the next four days hiking by myself
Tina: in
Shay: a beautiful national park. It was stunning and amazing. I loved it so much. I went back a few months later.
Like, I just did a whole bunch of things that,
that I,
yeah. Couldn't have done before that I felt like doing.
And it was really.
It was really, really magical. I really, really enjoyed that time.
And then.
Yeah, so I was really loving that. And I did the coach training honestly, because I kind of wanted to be coached, if that makes sense. I was like,
I signed up for it being like something is going to change for me through doing this and I don't know exactly what or how.
And so I signed up for it. And Martha Beck is a magical person and that was a really special experience and what I learned was really amazing. Go ahead.
Tara: Were you a Martha Beck fan before? Listening to the Way of Integrity?
Shay: No, I didn't know she existed.
Tara: Okay.
Shay: Because
Tara: I.
I had been a Martha Beck fan for more than 20 years.
Like I had. So I did life coach training back in 2005 and I wanted to do hers back then. And it's so funny. Like I think of if I had done it then I would have been like one of the first and.
But so it's interesting to me that you like just found her and it was. Right. And you know,
Shay: just
Tara: everything aligned
Shay: right. Well. Right. My whole life had fallen apart, you know,
had fallen apart. And so, yeah, I was just sort of.
Yeah, that's crazy. And I have some people, of course, like some people that I followed for several decades. Like that mine was Byron Katie that I. Yeah. Like I knew about her for forever and.
And yeah, that. I guess the Martha Beck thing just.
That book really changed my life in a beautiful way. And you know, that as, you know, like the teacher appears when,
when you most student is ready.
Tara: Yeah.
Shay: When the student is ready. So yeah, that's how, that's how the timing worked out for me. And so the coach training was really transformative.
It was really transformative. And what happened to me when I came out on the,
at the end of the training wasn't that I was like, okay, I'm gonna be a life coach now. It was things falling into place and like conversations and people coming into your life.
And again that the teacher appears when the student is ready. I was so. I had been really enjoying my freedom, kind of just believing that the magical Mr. Right would show up and we would figure out whether I was, we were going to adopt or try.
I, you know, try a crazy try IVF or figure it out.
And I,
is it okay to just like tell you this quickly how I ended up? Okay, So I was 42 and I was turning 43 in like three weeks. Like my 43rd birthday was coming up and I went to a birthday party of a kid, a friend who I love.
He was turning three at the time.
And at this birthday party I struck up a conversation with a mom of one of the other little three year, three year olds running around at this party and just really liked her.
And I remember noting that she seemed,
this is gonna sound really terrible,
I'm just gonna say it and we can cut it out if you need to. But I noted that she felt very like there is a twinkle in her eye instead of a deadened,
tired,
tired look that I feel like I noticed it. Most parents
Tara: have.
Shay: What ended what she, what I found out is that she was a single parent by choice.
I don't know that I'd really heard that term, honestly before this conversation with this woman.
And I was like, what? Why don't you tell me everything about that? And she was like,
yeah, I was like turning 40 and I knew I really wanted to be a parent. And so I,
I made it work for me. I figured it out. And I got pregnant with my daughter when I was 40 and she's three now,
best decision I've ever made in my life. And she just kind of was like,
I felt like, I don't know if she grabbed me by the shoulders, but it felt like she grabbed me by the shoulders and she said, you can do this,
you can do this.
And if you are considering,
basically she was just kind of like,
if you are thinking about being a parent and you want to be a parent or whatever, like, I highly recommend this. In fact, like, not only can you do this, but you should do this.
And I was like,
oh,
like,
wow. Like, this was a very interesting conversation. Anyway,
we exchanged contact information and the next day she even sent me. She sent me like a four minute long voice note where she was like, I just want to reiterate like,
you can do this. She's like, I know. I don't really know you. Like, I don't know what your job is. I don't know, whatever. And she's like, but, but, like,
I can just tell that you are.
That you would be a really great mom and that you can do this. And it was interesting. She actually said that she had some group or something she had joined online.
There was like,
there was a prize to talk to, I think a coach, maybe like a fertility coach or something that she won.
And she talked to someone and she said, I want to like, pay that forward to somebody else. And just that's why I'm calling you to say, like,
if you are thinking about doing this, like, you should do this. Do not let anything stand in your way.
What the heck? I don't. Like, that's incredible to me.
And so that was in late October,
and I.
I had just finished.
Or no,
I think I had just finished coaching school in the summer.
Tara: July. Yeah, I
Shay: had finished in July. It was October.
I'm turning. I was turning 43.
And this woman said this to me.
And this is.
Anyway, there just was such a convergence of things where I woke up, my eyes were so open and my mind and my heart were so. And it just.
I was like, whoa,
wait a second.
If. If I meet Mr. Right tomorrow,
I would have to,
like, he would have to be down to go on a crazy fertility adventure like yesterday.
Tina: Yeah.
Shay: And I don't want to do this with a stranger.
I don't not want to do this with a stranger.
Whoa. Like,
I have to be a single parent by choice if this is like, if this.
If I want to be a mom. It just sort of. It like all dawned on me kind of once it really hit me and then it was like,
it felt like,
like kind of a love story. It sounds like a rom com.
I. You have. You guys know that moment in a rom com where I think it's when Harry met Sally or whatever, when he is like, once you decide you want to spend the rest of your life with somebody,
you don't want to wait another day.
Like, let's get married tomorrow.
Do you guys know what I'm talking about? Yeah.
I now know that that was me and my daughter in that moment. I was like,
Tina: I can't
Shay: wait to Have a baby and I can't wait. It's gotta be like right now, like I want to be pregnant right now.
And so I knew that adoption wasn't going to be the way I was going to try first because in my mind adoption takes a long time and there's a lot of paperwork and like I'm very left brained.
And I was like that's right brained or left brain? Right brained. I'm very.
That was going to be a lot. Not
Tara: one paperwork. Yes.
Shay: Did not want paperwork.
And so I knew again that this was going to be a challenge for me. And I'm single person,
so financially this was good. You know, I didn't have many, many, many thousands of dollars to do this.
I knew that's what it was going to take in the States.
So I looked, I, I just,
I knew that not the United States was going to be my way forward because of how much things cost here in the medical system.
So I started googling IVF abroad.
I did some research.
Tina: Come up with that on your own or had somebody told you that it was cheaper?
Shay: There was another magical moment. It's such a great question and I forgot to tell you all.
I hope it's okay if I, if I flashback for a second. Do you, do you remember the moment when I was told by a 26 year old nurse practitioner that I was in early menopause when I was 38 years old and I wanted, I became the Hulk and I wanted to throw the exam table out the window and instead what I did was just put my clothes back on and I left that building.
I did not finish my exam. I left and subbed in my car. But I,
I startled the medical office when I left. I mean I, I called and was like that was unacceptable. That was absolutely insane.
And they were very sorry and they said when you come back you'll just see like the,
the gynecologist that runs the whole thing and he's a really beloved guy. And,
and he is, and he, he was, he was very, very, very special.
O B Y N I actually think he was in the documentary the Business of being Born super cool guy.
And this is so long ago. This was at the very beginning of when we didn't know yet what was happening with my fertility.
He said to me,
hey,
we don't know what's going on with you yet. This is the,
this is kind of a last resort.
But like IVF is always gonna be an option for you.
You know, we're not there yet, but go to Europe, it's a lot cheaper. There is what.
Tara: So he. He presents.
Shay: So he planted this seed. Yeah. And it was so, so long ago. So that's why I just was sort of like, I'm not even gonna again. I want to be pregnant tomorrow.
Like, I. I'm not even gonna mess around trying to figure it out with insurance and all that stuff. Stuff.
So I started Googling IVF abroad and.
That was in late October.
And I figured out a way and I got myself to Europe.
I had a friend who was living in London.
I stayed with her and her family for a fortune, for a little piece of time because I wasn't sure how long the whole thing was going to take.
And I ended up getting, you know, a $47 Ryanair plane to get to.
To Barcelona, Spain, which is where I ended up doing IVF and a fabulous clinic.
And long story short, I got pregnant in April.
So from. So I guess, yeah, that's how long it all took. And I was just absolutely stunned when I saw that positive pregnancy test. I mean, I could not have been.
Could not have been more stunned. I mean, there was it.
I will never forget that moment. Was it
Tara: your first try?
Shay: It was.
It was my first try, yeah. Yeah. Which is really.
It was just such a shock and.
And remains.
Remains a shock. Now my daughter is 10 months old.
In two days,
she is more spectacular that I could ever, ever have even allowed myself to imagine her being.
I actually had a really great pregnancy, even though I was told I was geriatric, like every 12
Tara: seconds
Shay: I had to be induced because, you know, we couldn't go past the 40 week mark,
which led to a C section. You know what?
It was not an emergency because it was unplanned, but I didn't allow it to be an emergency. I was able to meet like,
it happened that day. But I met the whole surgical team before I went in for my surgery a couple hours later.
I really liked them. I felt. I was totally terrified, but I felt I was in such good hands and it was such a calm environment because it wasn't,
it wasn't an emergency.
So,
you know, she came into the world in a different way than I thought she was going to, but it was very joyous and not scary,
other than having major surgery while you're still awake. Crazy experience,
really wild experience.
But I had a really,
I was, I was really fortunate to have a really talented and fabulous surgeon.
She came in the way she needed to come in and she is.
She's just been perfect every day of her Life, y'. All. I.
I don't know what else to say about it. She's the. She is like the light of my life.
There's.
I'm gonna stop there because there may be some questions.
I don't know if I went too fast through the rest of that.
Tara: Um,
I mean, to me, what.
And a little bit is just.
It seemed like,
almost miraculous, like, once you made that decision and you did have to figure a lot out.
But
Tina: to me, it's. You must be so proud of yourself,
Shay: you
Tina: know, Like, I. You did that. Like, that is. It's amazing.
Tara: Sounds. Yeah,
Tina: like.
Tara: Sounds hard, like, to go to another country and do this all
Tina: by yourself. Yeah, yeah. Like, every day you must wake up and be like, wow, I'm amazing.
Tara: And if you don't, then you should
Shay: really, really kind. And I do.
I do feel like it really felt.
I've never experienced it before, actually, in my life where I feel like the part I'm most proud of is I think, boy, I don't know how to say this in other terms.
People talk about. This is kind of a buzzy word, I think. But being in slow,
like, when you are in, like, when an athlete or whatever. When an athlete is out there doing their thing, they are not thinking, like, okay, now you have to jump, or, like, now you have to put your left foot forward or whatever.
They just are in a flow state, and they let their body do what their body is going to do, and they, like, trust.
They. They're very much, like, in trust with the universe that it's gonna.
That it's gonna happen.
And I think that is how it felt when that woman, when my friend said to me, like, you can do this.
And I was like,
the.
I just was like, I'm going to try this.
I'm gonna try this, and I'm gonna drop the rope. Essentially, I'm gonna let go.
And I had already cut loose, and I'm like, I'm gonna just see if this works. Like, it feels right to me. And I will never forget the thought where I did not feel like,
I hope this. I hope this works.
I don't know if this can work or whatever. I really felt, like,
really happy and really calmly like, I'm going to try this.
There was, like, a spark that felt like, I feel like this could work. I feel like this might work,
and wonderful it if it does. And. And so the part I'm the most proud of is staying.
So I stayed on the trust bus. That's what I call it. I stayed on the trust bus. The whole like, the whole time. There were definitely some moments where, I mean like I had some fearful moments for sure.
Some, some like twists and turns for sure,
but not a ton of them. And like, and, and I just, this is the way I handled it. I said, I am going to try this first. I'm going to look for,
for the clinic and then I'm going to have a conversation with the doctor at the clinic. Like that's,
you know, I'm gonna have this blood test, these blood tests done and I'm gonna send those results. And I just kept being like, one step at a time. Just do the next thing that you have to do and the timing will be out of your hands.
Like you can't,
you can't manipulate any of this. There's so much that is not in your hands. So I just, I stayed,
I stayed on the trust bus and I just was like, I'm just gonna take the next step.
And never before in my life has the path just appeared like, okay, now you do this and now you do this. And there were very few decisions honestly to make.
It was just sort of like you have kind of one option,
which was very freeing.
I mean I think that we all have decision fatigue. So I just was like, all right, I'm just gonna do this next because this is the,
this is the next step.
And so I am super proud of it. And the element that I am the most proud of is that I stayed in trust. That and I've never experienced this before.
It, it really, I was just in flow. Like the universe just kept coming and saying, okay,
you just opened this door, look straight ahead of you. The next door is right there. Just go open it and walk through it.
And,
and,
and then,
yeah. And then I had this baby. I could not believe it when they were like, okay, bye, you have to leave the hospital now. And I was like,
take her home.
It was just like really crazy. It was really crazy. And I just. There were many,
there were many sleep deprived moments in the beginning there where I just sobbed in the,
the most humility and like gratitude that,
that a person would be in.
And yeah,
they don't tell you this, but babies just keep getting cuter. It's wild.
They get cuter every single day. And I know that toddlerhood is coming. And she just started crawling and so I,
you know, I don't know how I'm going to take a shower. And when it's logistics get harder, but they get more,
they just get cuter every day.
Yeah.
And and more,
I think.
Yeah. She is my soulmate. And I am so glad that I didn't. I waited such a long time. I say I wasn't pregnant till I was 43 years old,
but.
But to me, I felt like the. Yeah, yeah. Like the minute that I made that decision, I was like, I don't want to wait anymore. I want to spend the rest of my life with this person.
And it turns out it's Charlie. My daughter Charlie. Yeah.
Tina: Yeah.
Tara: How. How has this transformation. Of course. How do you define transformation? Or how would you define transformation?
Shay: I think for me,
it was.
I think for me it's becoming myself, like, who I was when I was born,
and then all the. All the things happen and you forget and you have to, like, put on,
you know, you have to, like, put on so many other coats, and you're just kind of lost underneath a lot. A lot of layers.
And for me,
just that tiny thread of, like, being called to be a mom and not letting.
A lot, like,
not letting myself be deterred from just, like, really getting to that.
That. That kind of set me free. And I got to take off all those other layers. And now I'm so. I guess this last transformation, my most recent transformation, and I'm sure there will be more still, but I just feel like it's becoming.
Is me becoming who I really am.
And yeah, for me personally and I.
It was having a baby,
which is really strange, but I think, because a lot of people feel like maybe weighed down by that or that it's.
That that's like a huge responsibility. And it is, but for me, it. It set me free. My. My therapist said that to me at one point. She said that for you,
having a baby is going to be setting yourself free.
And that has been my experience so far with it. And so I hope that answers the question.
Tara: It does. Thank you.
Shay: Yeah.
Tara: And we are already running out of time.
Tina: So short.
Tara: I know. I. You're still working on the second transformation.
Shay: Yes. Yeah.
Tara: Of switching from professional photography to something new, which is related to what you've been through, and I'd love for you to just share some more of that.
Shay: I'll just say it really quick. I basically feel like because of my kind of decades of therapy,
the life coach training and a few other things, and then being. Going through this journey firsthand,
that.
Yeah, I'm just hoping to offer my services to help other people become parents if they want to become parents.
And in my case, I was. You know, I had a lot of cards, like a lot of Things stacked against me that, you know, like compromised fertility,
financial,
you know,
overwhelm with the US economy or medical system. Sorry.
And,
and then not being in a part partnership, like not being in a relationship,
all those things really felt like,
like a brick wall,
like insurmountable.
And,
and I was able to find a way.
And if I could do that for one other person,
it would be, it would be worth it.
And so I don't, it's,
it's not really just, it's not really a. Basically, there are many different people in a rainbow of different situations and I'm hoping that,
that to just reach anybody who is thinking about becoming a parent who are in any kind of alternative circumstance, you know, who like have anything going against that if they're considering single parenthood.
I would love to talk to you. I might have something to offer you.
So I don't know if it's coaching or consulting or an amalgamation, a combination of those things,
but I am putting,
putting that offer out there and hoping that I can find somebody to help again, sort of.
Yeah. Like pay that forward and, and help other people have this experience.
Tara: Yeah.
And I mean, I have experienced Shay's coaching and so I can vouch for that. That just feel like she is here to help people.
And,
and I know when you talk to me about it, it's not that you have the answers. I think it's more you want to help people kind of find their own answers.
Shay: Exactly. Right.
Tara: Yeah.
Shay: Very well said. Thank you so much for saying it that way, Tara. Yeah.
Tara: Yeah.
And to me, that's part of your story is just.
I felt like it was almost you finally.
Maybe finally isn't the right word, but you listen to yourself like that and that.
Shay: Yeah. Yeah.
Tara: All these miracles.
Shay: Yeah. It's so true.
And I, I, and I think,
yeah, I'll just say, like, I, I.
There's no regret. Like things happen the way that they happen. If I can help, help people come to that a little bit sooner and with a little less.
With a little less heartache.
Tara: Heartache.
Shay: Exactly. Exactly.
Tara: Yes, exactly. Yeah.
Shay: That's what I'm trying to do. Yeah.
Tara: What we. I'm so sad that our time is already up. But what is giving you joy right now,
Shay: Charlie? Eve Harrington, my little daughter. Yeah, she's just, you got. She's a joy machine. That's what I call her,
she machine.
And it's just like the greatest honor of my life to get to be witness to that every day.
And she's funny.
She's funny. She's Just, she's.
She's hilarious, she's kind,
she's warm,
she's delightful, she's curious,
and she is.
It's just the greatest honor to get to,
you know, to be.
To be her mom and.
And introduce her to the world and get to watch her get to.
Yeah,
I think I answered that with too many words, but,
no,
it feels indescribable.
Yeah, she is. And
Tina: I can
Tara: vouch that you. You've almost always called her a joy machine for
Shay: you.
Tara: Like, I mean, and so me asking that question, um, but I feel like, Shay, you are a joy machine, too.
Shay: That's.
That's so sweet. I heard one time, I remember early on somebody asking me about how it was going or something and how is motherhood. And I remember saying. And this.
It's just on theme for the transformation thing. I remember I was very postpartum, like, really in it, and I was like,
charlie is the big bang for me.
She has remade me.
She has, like, remade every cell in my body, so.
Tara: Oh, thank you.
Shay: Yeah. Yeah. Thank you so much for this opportunity. It was absolutely such a joy to get to talk to you both. Thank
Tina: you so much for sharing. I don't know. It was amazing to listen to. You're amaz.
Shay: You so much. Thank you so much. Tina. I. It was a pleasure to meet you. I hope I get to see you again sometime.
Tara: Thanks.
Tina: Thank you, Shay.
Shay: Thank you. fun.
-
Shay is finding joy right now in her little girl, Charlie Eve Harrington. Charlie is what Shay calls her “joy machine”.
Shay says, ”it's just like the greatest honor of my life to get to be witness to that every day. And she's funny, she's kind, she's warm, she's delightful, she's curious….It's just the greatest honor to get to be her mom and introduce her to the world.”.
-
About Shay McKenna -www.leftturnfertility.com
Shay McKenna is a certified Martha Beck Wayfinder Life Coach, photographer, and founder of Left Turn, a coaching and fertility consulting practice that helps people navigate the often overwhelming journey to parenthood.
After facing her own fertility challenges and questioning whether motherhood would ever be possible, Shay embarked on a transformative journey of self-discovery, courage, and trust. At 43, she traveled to Barcelona for IVF and became a mother to her daughter, Charlie, in December 2025.
Drawing on her personal experience, coaching training, and years of inner work, Shay now helps others move through fear, uncertainty, and seemingly impossible obstacles to find clarity and a path forward. Her story is a beautiful reminder that sometimes the life we want becomes possible when we listen to ourselves, let go of how we thought things were supposed to happen, and take the next step.
-
Resources Mentioned in This Episode
The Way of Integrity: Finding the Path to Your True Self — Martha Beck
Shay shares how discovering this book, almost by accident, helped her see her life more clearly and make some significant changes.
https://marthabeck.com/the-way-of-integrity/Martha Beck's Wayfinder Life Coach Training
The coaching program where Tara and Shay met. Shay describes how the training helped her better understand herself and navigate a period of significant change.
https://marthabeck.com/life-coach-training/Byron Katie — The Work
Shay mentions Byron Katie as someone whose teachings she has followed for many years. The Work is a process of questioning stressful thoughts and beliefs.
https://thework.com/The Way of Integrity — Free Companion Toolkit
A companion resource with exercises and a discussion guide for readers who want to explore the ideas in Martha Beck's book more deeply.
https://marthabeck.com/product/the-way-of-integrity-toolkit/Acadia National Park
Shay shares how a spontaneous solo hiking trip to Acadia became part of her journey of rediscovering herself and exploring what brought her joy.
https://www.nps.gov/acad/index.htm